E-cigarettes – just what the doctor ordered

14 Jun
E-cigarettes may help you to stub it out

E-cigarettes may help you to stub it out

News that the Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency will licence e-cigarettes as a medicine by 2016 (when new European tobacco laws come into force) has been widely reported this week. The directive, which will encompass all novel nicotine replacement products, reflects a commitment to ensuring quality and effectiveness.

The premise of e-cigarettes is that they allow people to carry on smoking without ingesting the horrible toxins which are known to be responsible for cancer. Given that around 100,000 people a year die of smoking-related diseases, the availability of e-cigarettes to help people wean themselves off the odious little cancer sticks must be a positive move.

An Action on Smoking and Health survey has revealed that 13% of smokers in the UK use e-cigarettes and they estimate that as many as 400,000 people have replaced smoking with puffing on an e-cigarette. The British Medical Association has tentatively welcomed the advent of e-cigarettes but calls for greater evidence of the safety and efficacy of the devices. Similarly, the National Institute for Clinical Excellence’s draft consultation paper on tobacco reduction highlights the lack of evidence around the long-term safety of e-cigarettes.

The reason that e-cigarettes are growing in popularity is, presumably, because they allow the smoker to enjoy the act of smoking without the associated health risks.

You see, smoking addiction is not just a physical craving, it has cognitive (I see smokers therefore I must smoke), emotional (I’m happy/ stressed) and social (let’s all be mates and smoke together) triggers.

I know this as back in the day I liked nothing better than kicking back after a hard day at work with a glass of chilled chardonnay and a fag. I finally stopped smoking with the introduction of the ban. Nothing’s that good to have to stand outside in the drizzle and cold to ‘enjoy’. Of course I relapse from time to time, usually as a result of a boozy evening out (a rarity since becoming a Mum).

But the cynic in me wonders if the manufacturers of e-cigarettes aren’t just trying to cash in on people’s smoking addiction – as nice as the people at NJOY and ahem, Marlboro are, I’m sure they don’t really have the world’s health on their conscience.

Furthermore, in Paris, apparently numerous bars are promoting the sale of e-cigarettes in various enticing colours and flavours. Now I’m no smoking cessation expert, but I would think that one of the first challenges in giving up smoking is breaking the association between holding a short stick in your hand and having an alcoholic drink…

In short, I don’t have a problem with e-cigarettes for those who need a temporary crutch to help beat their cravings. What I do take exception to is flagrantly encouraging the act of ‘smoking’ in bars and restaurants (and even on public transport). It somehow seems to go against all the progress made to reduce the visibility of smoking in public places.

I certainly hope that future generations – not least my own daughter – don’t feel the need to give smoking (electronic or otherwise) a try to be ‘in’ with the ‘in crowd‘. We’ve come so far with the smoking ban, it seems a shame to start making the act of puffing on a device masquerading as a cigarette acceptable.

Related links:

E-cigarettes face new restrictions

E-cigarettes are in vogue and at crossroads

ASH briefings – e cigarettes

BMA website – Tobacco / E-cigarettes

What’s the etiquette with electronic cigarettes?

Image credit: Copyright Piotr Marcinski / Dreamstime.com     Title: Tobacco addiction metaphor


3 Responses to “E-cigarettes – just what the doctor ordered”

  1. David Dorn (@Hifistud) June 14, 2013 at 3:54 pm #

    Do you also intend to prevent your daughter from trying her first coffee, alcoholic beverage or any other enjoyment-inducing products? You have to understand that, without the smoke (the REAL smoke) nicotine is as good as harmless – indeed, around as harmless as a cup of coffee.

    • Kate Mensah June 14, 2013 at 5:56 pm #

      Hi, I’d like to think I’m raising my daughter to make informed decisions about the products she consumes – and in actual fact stopping her from smoking (when she’s old enough) is probably a sure fire way to get her smoking! I suppose what I’m interested in is where smoking is going as a social trend and where e-cigarettes fit in. Certainly taking snuff and smelling salts are habits which have become unfashionable in modern times. If you were to push me I suppose I’d have to admit I don’t really want to see her smoking, although I take on board what you’re saying about the minimal health risks of nicotine in e-cigarettes. It will be interesting to see whether a new generation of smokers adopts this method of enjoying nicotine. My primary concern for my daughter will always be that she’s happy and healthy.

      • David Dorn (@Hifistud) June 14, 2013 at 6:04 pm #

        Indeed… My take on it is simple – if my grandson (currently only five months) fancies a drag on an e-cig once he’s old enough to understand what it’s all about, and his mum (my own nipper) and dad have no objections, then I’m cool with it. I’ve always thought forbidden fruit tastes sweeter, and it was probably because my own parents were so vehement about me not smoking (the hypocrites – they smoked at least 20 a day each!) that I was determined that I would!!
        I know, for instance, that Nicotine delivered cleanly (e-cigs, patches, gum etc) is minimally addictive – again, much the same as coffee. Indeed, had we always got nicotine in a nice mug with a forthy top and cinnamon sprinkles… well, you can see where I’m going..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

My Tights Won't Stay Up

Ever feel like you're starring in your own one-woman farce?

Dementia survivor, so far.....

My life with dementia so far

Truthful Loving Kindness

Person with Dementia Symptoms

Zoe Amar

Marketing and digital communications consultancy

Don Charisma

because anything is possible with Charisma

Leon Clifford

Expect to be challenged

Beth Crackles


Dr. Malcolm Kendrick

Scottish Doctor, author, speaker, sceptic

this is... The Neighborhood

the Story within the Story

stillness of heart



humourless mummy, cuddly feminist

Tales of Mother Hen

Short stories about a motley crew


art. popular since 10,000 BC

Gingerbread's campaign blog

Sharing single parents stories.

The Science of Mom

The Heart and Science of Parenting

Jack Monroe

The #1 budget recipe website

Trent Lewin

Fiction, and other made-up stories

%d bloggers like this: